Trivial Marital Disputes Not Dowry Harassment Under Section 498A IPC, Rules Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court recently held that simple or petty disputes between married couples cannot be treated as cruelty or dowry harassment under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The Court clarified that both cruelty and unlawful dowry demands must be present to convict someone under this section.
Justice P. Somarajan explained that just asking for dowry is not enough to attract Section 498A. The accused must also have subjected the wife to cruelty, either physically or mentally.
In this case, the wife claimed that her husband had demanded additional dowry and assaulted her. However, neither she nor any witness explained the nature of the alleged assault. The Court also found no medical evidence or proof of injuries.
What the Law Requires
The Court noted that to prove cruelty under Section 498A, the following must be established:
- There must be harassment related to an illegal demand for money or property.
- The harassment must be directed at the wife or her relatives.
- The harassment should be meant to force compliance with the dowry demand, or be a result of failure to meet it.
The Court explained that while the words “harassment” and “coercion” aren’t defined in IPC, they must be interpreted in light of the law’s purpose—to prevent dowry abuse.
Not Every Dispute Is Cruelty
The Court made it clear that small fights or arguments in marriage do not amount to cruelty. For a case to fall under Section 498A, there must be severe consequences, such as actions likely to cause the woman to commit suicide or suffer serious physical or mental harm.
Justice Somarajan also referred to earlier Supreme Court rulings, which warned against filing false or exaggerated complaints under Section 498A. He advised police authorities to be more careful when registering such FIRs.
Finally, since there was no solid evidence of cruelty or past incidents of violence, the High Court acquitted the husband and dismissed the case.
Case Summary:
- Court: Kerala High Court
- Issue: Dowry demand and cruelty under Section 498A IPC
- Judgment: Trivial disputes do not count as cruelty; conviction set aside
- Outcome: Husband acquitted, case closed
Be a part our social media community:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/IndianMan.in?mibextid=ZbWKwL
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/indianman.in?igsh=MWZ2N3N0ZmpwM3l3cw==
